Important events in OEC history.
Adam Beck born 20 June 1857 in Baden, Ontario
Conservative MPP Adam Beck leads march up Yonge Street demanding reliable and affordable Hydro.
Conservative government forms Hydroelectric Power Commission of Ontario ("HEPCO"). Adam Beck appointed first chair.
Under pressure from Municipal Electric Association, municipal leaders, Hydro-Electric Radial Union, electric railway supporters and impending election, Premier Borden revises Hydro-Electric Railway Act of 1913 to allow Ontario Hydro to isue bonds to finance radial lines
Sir Adam Beck dies August 15
NAFTA comes into force.
California passes law on deregulation of electricity to take effect in 1998
MacDonald Commission called for an end to Ontario Hydro's 90-year monopoly on generation.
Pickering "A" Station, approx 2,000MW, taken out of service for refurbishing, scheduled to return to service in 1999. Bruce "A" Reactors taken out of service and "mothballed" i.e. no scheduled date for return to service.
White paper "Direction for Change-Charting a course for Competitive Electricity and Jobs in Ontario"
Ice storm in Ontario and Quebec devastates electrical system, many areas(600,000 customers) without power for six weeks.
California deregulation goes into effect
Market Design Committee (MDC) established to advise government on market rules
Numerous Market Design Committee "consultations"continue with stakeholders in the Energy market. Later, it turns out that Enron representatives are represented on some of the advisory committee.
Electricity Act (Schedule A of Energy Competition Act) receives Royal Assent
Subsection 32(1) of the Electricity Act is proclaimed in force, providing for Rules for Grid and Market operation.
Ontario Hydro receives 16% return on investment in Luz del Sur (Peru).
Market Design Committee submits Draft Market Rules
Final Annual Report of Ontario Hydro indicates debt of C$30.5billion has steadily dropped from C$34.7billion in 1994
Energy Competition Act takes effect: Ontario Hydro broken into Ontario Power Generation (OPG), Ontario Hydro Services Company (OHSC), the Independent Market Operator(IMO) and the Electrical Safety Authority (ESA)
Y2K fears.
Energy Competition Act (and statutes "Electricity Act" and the "Energy Board Act") supersedes Power Corporation Act, ending Ontario Hydro's statutory existence.
Pickering "A" Nuclear Generating station, not returned to service as scheduled.
Y2K passes without incident
First issue of Market Rules for the Ontario Electricity Market.
Hydro One's work force reduced by 1,400 employees or about 25 per cent of the total regular work force through voluntary retirement program.
RBC Dominion reports that Alberta electricity prices increased from average $14.50 per MWH in 1996 to average $223.80 in fourth quarter of 2000. Alberta government announces residential and commercial electricity rates would be held constant for one year.
Alberta commences full retail competition.
California experiencing blackouts
Hydro One announces 2000 Financial Results. Revenues totaled $2,995 million versus $3,125 million in 1999. During 2000, Hydro One acquired 88 municipal electric utilities
Government of Ontario leases Bruce Nuclear Power Development to British Energy for approximately $1.8 billion for 18 years, with public responsibility for the billions of dollars of decommissioning costs. Annual revenue for 3,000 megawatts at regulated rates is approximately $1 billion; unregulated rates could almost double this sum. Two extra units are expected on line next summer. Thus, total revenue over 18 years of between $30 and $60 billion, which could have been used to retire the Hydro debt, was handed over to a private foreign corporation.
Official Opposition leader Liberal Dalton McGuinty invites energy barons to reception ($350 per person): "Throughout Ontario's electricity restructuring process, Dalton and the Ontario Liberals have been consistent supporters of the move to an open electricity market in Ontario."
Energy Minister Baird announces the province will go ahead with a $500 million tunnel under Niagara Falls to first supply more water to the existing electrical production facilities, then act as a feed for the third station.
Florida Energy 2020 Study Commission recommends that their market not be open to competition.
Premier Mike Harris announces plans to sell the province's electricity grid (Hydro One), and open the $10-billion electricity market to competition as of May 1, 2002.
Hydro One profit was $258 million in 2001
California experiencing "rolling blackouts"
Private owner of publicly built highway 407 allowed to increase toll for fourth time. Minister Stockwell had originally said that there was "no business case" for selling it.
Retailers sell fixed price electricity contracts for 5.7cents/kWh compared with Ontario Hydro energy cost of 4.3c/kWh
Leadership candidate Elizabeth Witmer is mocked by fellow Tories during leadership debate when she expresses doubts about hydro deregulation.
FERC approves sale of transmission rights for 975MW Lake Erie HVDC link connecting grid near Simcoe, Ontario with the U.S. at either, or both, of Springfield, Pennsylvania, and Ashtabula, Ohio.
Hydro One Networks Inc. and Cap Gemini Ernst & Young Canada Inc. have announced an agreement that will result in Inergi LP managing and operating existing business processes and technology enabled services for Hydro One.
California requests additional US$13billion refund from power giants. California State had to negotiate US$43billion of of long-term energy contracts during the crisis.
California Public Utility Commission ends experiment with energy deregulation, retroactive to September 20.
Sir Adam Beck, with assistance of OEC, writes to congratulate Premier Eves on assuming Premiership, and urges him to rescind the sell-off of Public's Hydro assets by his predecessor.
Province files preliminary prospectus for sale of shares of Hydro One
OEC challenges secret study by C.D.Howe study by F. Lazar which claims there will be benefit from open market.
OEC launches advertising campaign. Thousands call and e-mail politicians
Ernie Eves, recently returned from stint at Bank Credit-Suisse-First Boston, sworn in as premier.
Superior Court Justice Arthur Gans rules province has no legal authority to sell off its electricity grid, Hydro One.
Government holds sham hearings across province in preparation for new bill to privatize Hydro One. Energy Minister Chris Stockwell bolts from public hearings on privatization of Hydro One amid heckling
Electricity generation market finally opens to competition, following two previous deferred openings.
Prices fall below pre- open-market price of 4.3 cents per kilowatt hour.
Government introduces legislation to skirt court ruling so it can sell Hydro One.
42 Ontario city and town councils, representing 6 million citizens, pass resolution opposing opening of market. Thousands of Ontarians continue to call and e-mail Conservative politicians.
All external members of the Board of Directors of Hydro One, including chairman Sir Graham Day, resign on the heels of legislation introduced in the Legislature to fire the directors.
Interim Hydro One board appointed
Eves kills plan to sell Hydro One, says province will maintain majority share in company.
Government passes laws to sell Hydro One and fire board of the transmission utility.
Demand for power reaches record levels amid unusually hot weather. Bills shoot up.
Stockwell pleads with public to conserve power.
Board of Hydro One terminates CEO Eleanor Clitheroe for cause over out-of-control spending. Tom Parkinson appointed President and COO.
John Spears, Toronto Star reports that "out-of-province" electricity generators getting paid up to $2 a kilowatt hour for electricity, while Ontario generators getting at most 47 cents. Investor Duane Cramer Sithe Energies Canada VP says says Sithe is now reflecting on its options for the gas-fired plants it plans for Ontario.
Government announces new board of directors for Hydro One. Glen Wright (Chair) Geoff Beattie, Rita Burak,Murray Elston, Dr. Murray Frum, Don MacKinnon, Eileen Mercier, Dr. Heather Munroe-Blum, Hon. Bob Rae, Kenneth D. Taylor, Adam Zimmerman
Eves splits energy and environment portfolio. John Baird takes over as energy minister.
Market supply operator implements three per cent voltage cut lasting 20 minutes.
Opposition begins almost daily attacks on Eves government over personal hardship caused by high prices.
Independent Electricity Market Operator warns Ontario faces ``serious shortage'' of generating capacity.
The Stakeholders Alliance of Electricity Competition & Customer Choice (SAC) David MacFadden believes Ontario is on the right track but reforms in the market are necessaryto overcome serious impediments to achieving success.
Eves proposes measures to protect consumers from skyrocketing hydro bills, a freeze on rates and rebates to May 1 for consumers who paid rates above the cap. Bill requires "for-profit" utilities to confirm their status or revert to "non-profit" which limits fundraising capability for maintenance or development - a catch 22. Disconnections for unpaid Bills disallowed until April 1.
The Toronto Board of Trade, a long-time proponent of an open electricity market, firmly believes that the imposition of new terms and conditions on Ontario's recently opened electricity market is a mistake.
Legislature passes Bill 210 into law, essentially closing retail market.
Ontario paid $110 million to generator companies in December to subsidize power
OEC reacts to Toronto Star report that Federal Government officials are now preparing a proposal that would establish a North American energy zone.
Eves announces that none of Hydro One will sold.
OEC release: "Eves has been forced by public pressure to keep Hydro One public but he is still pushing ahead with the worst of his electricity policy: for-profit, electricity generation in a deregulated electricity market. The big cost on your Hydro bill is the cost of generating the electricity - and that's where the big profits are for private producers."
Ontario consumed 24,158 megawatts of power Wednesday, the highest since January 1994 The price of electricity rose to $122.18 a megawatt at 2 p.m. in Toronto, more than double the average price of 51.62 since the electricity market was opened to competition May 1, and almost triple the provincial cap of $43
Sault Star reports POWER (People Opposing Whitewashing Electrical Rates) group oppose high Great Lakes Power (Brascan) electricity costs. Wawa City supports residents following door-to-door survey indicating that 52 per cent would place their hydro payment into escrow to protest the high cost of electricity since deregulation
Number of unpaid hydro bills skyrockets. Many utilities in financial difficulty.
Ottawa Electrical Utility declares itself "for-profit" under protest. Limits dividend to $1.
OEC recommends public utilities to commit to profit under protest, and posts proposed resolution (see "Articles").
Hydro One 2002 year end results show net income of $344 million and revenues of $4,044 million. Revenue increased $578 million or 17%, over last year, to $4,044 million for year 2002.
Due to parent British Energy financial difficulty in UK, 82.4% stake in Bruce Power sold. Cameco acquires additional 16.6 per cent interest, for a total of 31.6%, and unions get increased share.
Holdings are: TransCanada PipeLines Limited (31.6 per cent); BPC Generation Infrastructure Trust (OMERS)(31.6 %), The Power Worker's Union (4.0%) and The Society of Energy Professionals (1.2%). As well, the consortium acquired British Energy's 50% interest (with OPG 50%) in Huron Wind, Ontario's first commercial wind farm with five 1.8 MW turbines.
Hydro-Quebec study of electricity rates in 11 Canadian cities shows Edmonton with highest average residential consumer electricity price, 11.18 cents per kilowatt hour, as of May 1, 2002. Industrial Association of Southern Alberta say botched deregulation is to blame for soaring power prices
Campbell family, private owners of Gananoque Hydro, informs Energy Board they will cease business February 28, and resists takeover by interim authority as "an act of trespass and expropriation without compensation."
IMO reports that Weighted Average electricity price for month of February is $88.59/MWh, compared with pre-market price of $43.
Government freeze on disconnections comes to an end. "Our government has taken concrete steps to protect consumers, including freezing the price of electricity at 4.3 cents per kilowatt hour and providing immediate relief to the majority of consumers with a $75 rebate cheque," said Energy Minister John Baird. "Consumers who are in arrears must act responsibly and contact their local utility to settle any outstanding accounts. The reality is electricity is not free."
Inquiry called to look into Pickering "A" NGS, nearly 3 years overdue and $1.2 billion over budget. Inquiry by Chier Jake Epp (former Conservative Energy Minister under Mulroney), Robin Jeffery (former head of British Energy, operators of leased Bruce NPD) and Peter Barnes (former secretary to Ontario Cabinet). One unit scheduled to restart later this year.
April 2003 IMO reports Year-to-date Weighted Average price of electricity was $62.18/MWh for energy, but with other charges (Market Service Charges, Transmission costs, and Debt Retirement charges) the consumer bill would look like $84.74/MWhh.
The Board of Directors of Hydro One Inc appoints. Tom Parkinson as President and Chief Executive Officer of Hydro One Inc.
Throne speech includes only 3 lines about Electricity system, Conservatives (and Liberals) want to avoid it being an issue.
Expected call of Provincial election delayed, ostensibly due to SARS crisis return, but likely due to PC unpopularity in polls.
IMO warns of need to import more electricity this summer
Energy Minister John Baird appoints panel to look into delays and cost overruns for the 2,000MW Pickering A Rehabilitation, and to make recommendations. The Panel is chaired by Jake Epp (former Fed Min of Energy), Peter Barnes is the chair of George Brown College Dr. Robin Jeffrey worked with Bruce Energy which was a partner in Bruce Power. The report is scheduled for December 31, 2003.
Transalta buys $24m excess transmisson contracts due to computer error.
Government selects proposals for portable generators (total 409MW) in Southern Ontario. Estimated cost $100million (excluding energy costs) surprises Eves. Three of seven bidders had donated to Tory party, including Toromont-Cat ($821), TCPL ($7500) and Toronto Hydro ($349)
Vice-Chair Rita Burak (Pres & CEO of Network Executive Team) appointed interim Chair of Hydro One Inc., replacing Glen Wright.
Former Energy Minister Stockwell resigns as minister of environment and government house leader pending investigation by integrity commissioner Justice Coulter Osborne into financing by Ontario Power Generation of Stockwell trip to Europe in summer of 2002.
Ontario Energy Board fines Direct Energy ( $157,500 for 21 offences) and Ontario Energy Services Co. ($75,000 10 contraventions)
IMO 18mo outlook indicates possible severe shortages for July, reports that Pickering units are not expected to return to sevice on schedule. Toronto Star reports that costs to date for refurbishment of Pickering A are C$2.5billion, which is C$1.3 over budget.
US Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) votes to strip bankrupt Enron Corp. of some of its rights to trade electricity and natural gas after finding the company manipulated electricity prices during California's energy crisis of 2000-01. Enron will be allowed only to "wind down". In March a FERC staff report found that ENRON unfairly gained US$3.2billion from manipulating the Gas market
Ont Govt establishes Electricity Conservation and Supply Task Force to look at new ways to attract generation, and to identify mechanisms for demand-side reduction, and conservation.
Co-chairs Gunnars Cecksters (Enersource) and Peter Budd (Chair of Ontario Energy Association, a pro-open market association of energy suppliers) and 16 other members, mostly with an interest in, or supporters of an open market. Two one-day public hearings are promised.
Atlanta-based Mirant filed Chapter 11 after it was unable to persuade its creditors to extend their loans. At $19.4 billion It is the 11th largest bankruptcy in U.S. history.
The two largest US banks, Citigroup Inc and J.P. Morgan Chase & Co agreed to pay a total of $308 million to settle federal and state charges that they helped Enron manipulate financial statements. Last March, Merrill Lynch & Co. paid $80 million to settle SEC charges that Merrill and four of its executives helped Enron fraudulently book income. [NY Newsday.com July29 2003]
The largest blackout ever to hit North America, leaves 50 million people without electricity for 24 hours. Originating with a fault in the deregulated state of Ohio, it quickly spread to Ontario, New York, and Philadelphia, and Michigan. It took Ontario nearly a week to lift the Emergency status.
Transformer fault blacks out London |England]
Ben Glisan, treasurer of Enron Corporation pleaded guilty to a federal conspiracy charge and became the first executive sentenced to prison in the scandal that toppled the energy giant. He was sentenced to the maximum penalty of five years. [From the Toronto Star 11 Sept 2003, page D2]
After deferring the issue since April to May to June to July to September, Toronto City Council voted to reconsider its position in favour of for-profit City Hydro, request the Government of Ontario to: rescind Bill 210 which disadvantages non-profit utilities, abandon it splan to deregulate and privatize Ontario's electricity system; stop the sell-off of public generating stations and local hydro utilities; stop paying higher deregulated prices to electricity producers; and implement genuine energy conservation policies and expand clean renewable energy resources.
Blackout in Italy after a tree brings down a line on an interconnect from Switzerland
Eves calls election
Ontario Election: Eves Government swept out by Liberals under Dalton McGuinty. Dwight Duncan MPP for Windsor, appointed Energy Minister
In a speech to the Empire Club and following an audit of the Provincial books revealing a $5.6billion deficit, McGuinty announces that he will abandon his promise to maintain the electricity price freeze.
It is also revealed that the Eves government had intended to raise money to cover the secret $5.6 billion deficit by arrangements with the private sector to buy outright, or benefit from the income of, the LCBO and Hydro One.
Contrary to a pre-election promise to maintain the energy freeze till 2006, the month-old Liberal government introduced legislation (Ontario Energy Board Amendment Act) lifting the cap of 4.3 cents per kilowatt hour. As of April 1, 2004, electricity rates will be 4.7 cents per kilowatt hour - for the first 750 kilowatt hours of power used. Anthing above that will cost 5.5 cents per kilowatt hour.
This means it will cost an extra $3 a month for a home that uses 750 KwHr. The average Ontario home uses about 860 KwH a month. Energy minister Dwight Duncan says the cost of maintaining the "freeze" (subsidizing energy producers) is about $700 million dollars a year.
Energy Minister Dwight Duncan today released the Report of the Pickering A Review Panel. The investigation was chaired by Jake Epp, former Federal Conservative Energy Minister.Minister Duncan accepted the resignations of OPG's Chairman, Bill Farlinger, the CEO, Ron Osborne, and COO, Graham Brown. An interim CEO, Richard Dicerni, who currently serves as Executive Vice-President and Corporate Secretary of OPG, has been appointed. In addition, a Shareholder Resolution has been passed which limits the power of the Board and ensures that all major decisions are approved by the shareholder.
A report by Courtney Pratt, CEO of Stelco, formerly Toronto Hydro, formerly Hydro One warns the Liberal Government of insufficient power in just two years because the consumption of electricity keeps rising while supply remains nearly stagnant and much of the generation capacity is reaching pensionable age with no replacements in sight.
The task force advises that Ontario maintain its coal plants until adequate new plants are in place or conservation measures yet to be announced have reduced demand. The Liberals have promised to remove them from service by 2007.
Andrew Fastow, Enron’s former chief financial officer, pleads guilty to two counts of fraud in a plea bargain with prosecutors. Fastow agreed to cooperate in future investigations and received a 10-year prison sentence
Former Enron chief executive officer Jeffrey Skilling was indicted on 35 counts of fraud, conspiracy and insider trading. He was released after posting a $5 million bond. Former chief accounting officer Richard Causey, previously indicted in January on six counts of fraud, was also charged in this new indictment. The indictment said Skilling between 1998 and 2001 received about $200 million from the sale of Enron stock and stock options, netting more than $89 million, and received more than $14 million in salary and bonuses.Causey reportedly received $14 million from stock and stock option sales, netting more than $5 million, and received more than $4 million in salary and bonuses.
Kenneth Lay, chairman of Enron’s board of directors and CEO of the company is yet to be indicted
The Ontario Energy Board says the government should set up a conservation agency to help industries and residents reduce their use of electricity and fund its operations through a charge on power.
A 3 person commission that scrutinized Ontario Power Generation, led by former Deputy Prime Minister John Manley, former Bank of Nova Scotia Chairman Peter Godsoe, and Jake Epp, a former Ontario Energy Minister issues report which recommends, among other things:
McGuinty government announces the formation of Ontario Power Authority with policies for the primary goal to create confidence among investors. The price of power next year will be based on a blend of regulated power price, plus the variable market established price of private power suppliers. According to the IMO, since the market opened, the hourly price has averaged 51cents per KWh.
The power behind public electrical power in Ontario.
On University Avenue just south of Queen Street West stands a statue of Ontario's champion of publicly owned at-cost electricity, Sir Adam Beck. In the early 1900's, Beck battled and defeated private power producers who sought to capture and exploit the new electricity market in Ontario. He built a powerful grassroots movement which was able to set public policy at Queen's Park and withstand attacks from powerful financial interests in England and the United States.
Beck served as Mayor of London, as Member of Provincial Parliament and Chairman of the Hydro Electric Power Commission, later known as Ontario Hydro.
In 1906, Beck led a march of 2000 people from Toronto's City Hall up University Avenue to the Parliament Buildings to demand legislation to break the grip of the private power producers.
A breakthrough came in 1910 in Kitchener, then named Berlin, Ontario. Crowds and banners lined the streets as Beck, Chairman of the Hydro-Electric Commission, threw a ceremonial switch and public at-cost power reached the city. Crowds went wild as electric light bulbs spelt out the slogan "For the people!".
In the forefront of those who opposed Beck's movement was one of the richest men in Toronto: Henry Pellett - owner of the Electrical Development Company. In a city in which thousands lived in desperate conditions, he quickly amassed a fortune through his control of the city's electrical supply - a fortune large enough to build a castle - Casa Loma.
The super profits of private power "robber barons" like Pellett, proved Beck's point - electricity should be generated and distributed at-cost, in the interests of the people, not for the profit of the few.
Interest in Beck has been renewed as opposition grows to the Government of Ontario's plans to privatize and deregulate electricity in this province.
The struggle for public power was not without cost to Beck. In a passionate speech in 1913, Beck stated, "I have given twelve years of my life to this movement. I'll die ten years before I'll need to have died, because I have given up my business, my home, my everything to make this movement a success, not for any profit it can give me or any glory I want. We have fought our battles, we have won our victory...."
Beck was born June 20, 1857 in Baden Ontario and died in London Ontario, August 15, 1925.
Statue of Sir Adam Beck

The engraving on the statue reads:
"Erected by the Corporation of the City of Toronto and the Toronto Hydro Electric Commission in grateful commemoration of the public service of Sir Adam Beck, whose labours have ensured that the citizens of his native province under co-operative municipal ownership, shall enjoy the benefits of low-cost electrical energy derived from water-power resources to serve the industrial and domestic needs of the Province of Ontario."
CONTACT US:
Ontario Electricity Coalition
890 Yonge St. Suite 1001
Toronto, Ontario, M4W 3P4
For Media: Paul Kahnert, 647-654-9084
Email